How to measure and improve your agency's retention rate
How to calculate policy retention for a small independent agency, why it's the number that drives agency value, and what to do about the renewals you lose.
Retention is the share of the business you had that you kept. For an independent agency it is the number that matters most: a renewal costs far less to win than a new client, and an agency’s value is largely the value of the book it keeps.
How to calculate it
The simplest measure is policy retention over a period, usually twelve months:
Retention = policies up for renewal that renewed ÷ policies up for renewal
Count only the policies whose renewal came due in the period. Leave out new business written in the period; it isn’t retention.
For example: 400 policies came up for renewal this year, 352 renewed, 48 were lost. Retention is 352 ÷ 400 = 88%.
Two other views are worth a look once you have the first:
- Premium retention: the same, with premium instead of a count. A few large commercial accounts can move it more than many small personal ones.
- Client retention: by household or business rather than by policy. A client who keeps home but moves auto shows up here differently.
Know why each renewal was lost
A retention rate says how much; the reasons say what to do. For every lost renewal, record:
- the reason: price, coverage, service, the client moved, sold or closed the business, or went direct;
- who took it, if you know;
- whether it’s worth winning back.
After a few months, patterns appear. If most losses are price on one line with one carrier, that’s a marketing problem you can work on. If they’re service, it’s a process problem.
Work renewals early
Most losses that can be prevented are prevented early: a review call 60 to 90 days out, before the renewal notice arrives and the client starts shopping. Renewals worked in the last week are the ones most likely to be lost on price.
Win-back
A client lost on price may come back a year later, when their new carrier raises the rate. Note lost accounts worth chasing, and look at them again about 90 days before their next anniversary.
Tracking it in Renewal Book
Renewal Book records every renewal as renewed, won or lost, with the reason, who took it and whether to try again. The Lost list shows the reasons over time, and accounts flagged for win-back come back to you before their next anniversary. Because each policy works through the same stages, from not started to renewed or lost, the numbers above come from the work you’re already doing.
More guides
- How to track insurance renewals and stop missing themA simple system for a small independent agency to see every renewal coming, work each one on time, and know what happened to it.
- The insurance renewal spreadsheet, and a free templateThe columns an agency's renewal spreadsheet needs, how to lay it out so it stays useful, and a free blank template to download.
- How to track commissions at a small insurance agencyWork out what each carrier owes you, check what was actually paid, and catch the short payments, without an accounting system.
- A 90-day renewal checklist for independent agenciesWhat to do 90, 60 and 30 days before a policy renews, and on the day, so renewals are worked early and nothing lapses.